Think over what you’ve bought in the last month. What was actually ‘worth’ what you paid and what was ridiculously marked up… some things may jump out at you like that Louis Vuitton purse or an iPod Touch, but somewhere deep down you think defensively ‘well it is really well made or has extreme technological advances’. Here is the answer though, EVERYTHING you bought in the last month was ridiculously marked up!! And if you can understand why and harness that power for yourself you’ll come to see the beauty of perceived value.

Today I was at Borders looking for a moleskin the legendary notebook of Van Gogh, Picasso and Chatwin and on the sale shelf something caught my eye, something that looked exactly like my beloved moleskin yet was a steal for $5.99. How could this be I thought, surprised at my good fortune… but a look closer at the notebook showed it was really a “Piccadilly”, a company that makes notebooks worldwide and I guess thought it would be a good idea to challenge the original moleskin’s by making ‘knock offs’ and selling them for half price.

As you can see, things that end up on the bargain bin usually aren’t big hits. When is the last time you saw Jimmy Choo, Lexus or Gucci having a half off sale? So why did Piccadilly’s replicas fail and Moleskin’s incredibly high priced notebooks ($16.99 for a basic, ya know, notebook) succeed? Perceived value my friend, it is all in how you feel about the product, and people just weren’t feelin’ Piccadilly.

Was it the name? Maybe, but the better guess is that people felt ‘scammed’ by the blatant knock off and made a series of excuses in their head why they just had to have the Moleskin. It’s better quality (it’s not, I checked both back to back and they are pratically identical save for a made in China stamp on the Piccadilly)  I just like Moleskin better (that is like saying you think one identical twin is hotter than the other, come on) or maybe the buyer assumed that since Moleskin was priced higher it was better made and worth more… thus going with it instead of it’s identical twin priced at half the cost.

This is bad news for consumers, but good news if you are an entrepreneur, start up fiend or interested in escaping the 9 to 5 by replacing your income via selling something.

5 lessons I’ve learned from perceived value

  1. Branding is vital. A highly recognizable branded item or service can go for as much as 100x the price of it’s competition because people will equate the brand with quality and thus are more likely to buy it vs. it’s cheaper counterpart. Example: MAC vs. Acer computers (argue me on quality, but when it comes down to it you buy the MACbook because it ‘feels’ right).
  2. Go higher, not lower. Often when small businesses start up they have competition, usually this means the entrepreneur cuts prices on their item to make it more ‘appealing’ what they don’t realize though is often that’s  the worst kind of sabotage. First off it makes it harder to turn a profit and stay in business and secondly their market may indeed mistrust them for their steep discounts instead of giving the new business their loyalty.
  3. When you go higher it is a win win… usually. From the moment I started out I over priced my products, services, etc. At least over priced in the sense of I had no experience and was kind of just swinging wildly hoping to hit on something. So was it a risk? Absolutely, but one thing it taught me – a huge lesson – was that when someone believed in me and paid me above what deep down I felt I was worth it made me worth more and preform better. So if you are selling a widget and your two choices are sell it for below market standards or above I say go high, then make the product that much better to justify the price.
  4. Always be ready with your story. Sometimes people will call you out on a high priced item, but if you have a killer story behind it and reason WHY it is priced like it is 9 times out of ten you win. I have had countless people challenge me on my prices, to that I give them a long winded, incredibly detailed explanation of why, what and how I do what I do. This “story” is so well crafted and repeated that it is compelling enough to usually turn even my strongest critic into an ally and it wins their business because I have a WHY behind me asking them to ‘buy’.
  5. Perceived value usually goes up the longer you are in business. This is not across the board but it is a generalization, people trust company’s who have been in business for years hence why banks have ‘serving you since 1968 engraved in stone outside their headquarters. So the longer you stay in business the more perceived value you can rake in if you are savvy. Look at Chanel, do you think Coco immediately started out selling $1000 bags and charging a premium? No, she started out with a great stride, charging more than the stuff was ‘worth’ technically but as she grew her brand her prices skyrocketed as well, in turn skyrocketing the brand and the perceived value. This circular logic may get confusing but does work, time and time again.

So how can you use perceived value?

Firstly, honestly look at your product and/or services? Do you REALLY think it is worth what you charge for, if you think its below par then make it better, if you think it is above then charge more. Regardless figure out way to be the Bentley of your market via the Kia.

Secondly, when you buy for yourself remind your emotional brain that dropping $500 for Champagne is just silly, then if you like go ahead and do it… but be sure to off set that ridiculous expense with some perceived value upping of your own.

Share →
  • http://40daystochange.wordpress.com/ ami@40daystochange

    another excellent post. I particularly like your suggestion to price high – then make sure your product lives up to its pricing, great strategy for a high quality brand.

    My question: did you end up feeling Piccadilly – or did you stick with your beloved Moleskin? ;)

  • http://jamieontiveros.com/ Jamie Ontiveros

    The psychology of pricing is very interesting. I'm in the process of starting up a web app, and pricing is going to be a big hurdle. Naturally, I don't want to price to high, but don't want to leave anything on the table either. Thanks for this post. There is a lot to think about here.

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    I bought the Piccadilly even though at first my urge was to go for Moleskin – I was like “Maren, don't be a snob” and stocked up for cheap!

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    Hi Jamie, that is awesome. What kind of app?

  • http://daringclarity.com/ Lana {Daring Clarity}

    Awesome Maren and so true! It is our scarcity mindset that is not allowing us to raise prices (what if noone will buy?). The moment we ourselves start believeing that we deserve to be paid high, the world responds accordingly.

  • http://www.mastermindblogger.com S Ahsan

    Awesome tips… you impress me all the time Maren.. “Branding is vital.” agreed and i am working on mine. Thanks a lot for the amazing posts.. looking forward to more.. Cheers

  • James Ward

    I could not agree with this post any more, even if I wanted.
    I have had to “justify” my companies pricing. And yes, it did cause us to work to show the why. And becuase of this, we have seperated ourselves from most of our competition.

  • http://andbreak.com/ Julius Kuhn-Regnier

    I like your thoughts on this one Maren. The best example of how high the perceived value of a product can be is Apple. I mean common, all of the iPods are priced at such a high price, other MP3 players cost less than half the price of iPods. Of course iPods are great but I think Apple has really mastered how to use branding as a way to create a higher value for their products. Their strategy simply works.
    Btw. how is your car buying strategy working out? Have you bought the new car yet?

  • http://jamieontiveros.com/ Jamie Ontiveros

    Good for you. I have never heard of Piccadilly notebooks before, but would have opted for the more practical choice too. I bought a bunch of Moleskins a few years ago and never used them, so I gave them away as Christmas presents. :)

  • http://jamieontiveros.com/ Jamie Ontiveros

    I have more than a few ideas, but the first one is going to be an app for accountants and finance types.

  • http://experimentsinpassiveincome.com/ Moon Hussain

    Maren, well thought out post. Perceived value is something I've been a victim of but it's interesting psychology. Some people are frugal and never stray, but some justify the product by the high price. “It's high because of the quality”. Sure ;)

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    It is true Lana :) I hope more people catch on to that positive thinking!

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    Thank you :) Branding really is, I am learning more and more about it each day!

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    Exactly! See a real life example, thanks for sharing James :)

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    It is in process, I am having someone build out the site where I will direct sponsors so they can sign up for the year & “Commit” then after I have the proper number to justify the price per month i'll do it :)

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    Yep, it is ALL in your mindset, some things people will pay for, some they won't… you want to capture the market and be the brand that people line up to pay for.

  • http://harvestwages.com/ innocriss

    hello Maren,
    Perceived value is really a matter of branding and popularity. “If you see your products of services low, consumers too will see it as such”. I think most failing companies just don't value their own products. Most companies don't know how to analyse their consumers opinions.

  • http://www.marsdorian.com/ Mars Dorian

    It's true
    And Apple is a perfect example – they truly dominate this aspect.
    Buy a PC and you're average, run-of-the-mill, buy a MAC and you're member of a special, elite group of user that only exist in your mind. Same goes for Mercedes.
    And I also think that you have to become a Brand that is sooo awesome and remarkably different that you can actually demand those prices.
    Time to get to work :=)

  • http://www.diary4life.com Paul

    Maren,

    A very interesting post; I like the 5 lessons you've learnt. No. 1 -brand – is particularly important, without it your chasing shadows.

    Regards

    Paul

  • matthewneedham

    Hi Maren, some great advice here and as I compete in a field where there are a number of others esentially performing the same services, this is what I have to do.

    However, the most important question which you didn't answer is did you buy the Moleskine?

  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    I know, I always catch myself under valuing myself as well :) it is such an easy trap to fall into… seeing the glass as half empty vs. half full

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    That is funny I was at the MAC store today and was just like “Wow, this is such a cult” but that is what the company wants and why they are doing so great.

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    Branding is such a difficult balance, you need it badly to succeed but you don't want your company's brand to define your life's destiny necessarily.

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    I bought the Piccadilly! I was not going to lose 12 bucks even though my mind said “buy the Moleskin” :)

  • http://www.stevescottsite.com/ Steve Scott Site

    Excellent breakdown of perceived value. You can definitely increase the dollar value that you charge for a product simply by adding stuff makes it more expensive.

    On the flip side, I've seen a lot of sleazy marketers use perceived value as a way to mask inferior information. They slap some videos and audios on to the product and give the perception that they're giving away quality stuff.

    But on a whole if you have an excellent product, then perceived value can really skyrocket your income.

  • http://www.Escapingthe9to5.com/ Maren Kate

    That is true, perceived value can be used for good or for “evil” (As with everything it seems) but if you do have a good product and even better can convince others WHY it is good for them you can make a killing and feel good about it.

  • http://www.stevescottsite.com/ Steve Scott Site

    Exactly! I like to think that marketing can be good if you know if you're helping people get past their skepticism and use your product to solve their problems.

  • http://www.stevescottsite.com/ Steve Scott Site

    Exactly! I like to think that marketing can be good if you know if you're helping people get past their skepticism and use your product to solve their problems.